Hospital director files lawsuit - Hi-Desert Star: News

Hospital director files lawsuit

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 12:00 am

JOSHUA TREE — A physician and director of Hi-Desert Memorial Health Care District filed suit against the hospital district this month, alleging his fellow doctors and Chief Executive Officer Lionel Chadwick retaliated against him for complaining about poor care.

Dr. Dennis Wilcox of Pioneertown, who was appointed to the district’s Board of Directors in 2008, filed his complaint March 8 in Riverside court.

He alleges the hospital, its doctors and its leaders violated his civil rights and retaliated against him when he expressed concerns that the care at the Hi-Desert Medical Center was “substandard,” and that certain providers “acted contrary to the best interest of the patients there.”

The health care district’s attorney issued a statement denying the allegations.

“The Medical Center believes Dr. Wilcox’s lawsuit is both procedurally and substantively meritless,” the statement reads.

Named in the suit are the district, Hi-Desert Medical Center, the hospital’s Medical Executive Committee, Chadwick and 10 doctors.

Wilcox and his attorneys are demanding a jury trial.

They allege that after Wilcox entered into agreements to provide medical services in the health care district in May 2007, he “became aware of serious medical care and treatment deficiencies at the hospital and became pro-active in addressing these.”

Wilcox provides several examples of experiences he alleges are representative of common practices at HDMC.

The most serious describes a 76-year-old woman whose colon was punctured during a routine colonoscopy. According to Wilcox, instead of admitting her to the hospital, the staff gastroenterologist sent her home. She developed an infection that eventually killed her.

He details several more cases of infections, ruptured appendixes, kidney stones, heart problems and cancers that he says were misdiagnosed or inappropriately treated, but were not up for discussion when he brought up his concerns.

The doctor claims he found that patients are endangered when they must wait for treatment at Hi-Desert Medical Center because many of its specialists don’t live nearby and “it is inconvenient for them to drive to Hi-Desert and attend patients who may or may not be able to pay them.”

He alleges the hospital staff “delay critical treatment to the patients to accommodate the practitioner’s own medical schedule.”

Wilcox claims the situation is so common the hospital staff has a name for it — the “Hi-Desert Delay.”

Wilcox maintains that he was continually “cut off and intimidated” from communicating with Medical Executive Committee members or staff administrators.

His suit alleges that the district and medical committee reported him to the California Medical Board “with the intention to seek a revocation of Wilcox’s medical license.”

He contends the doctors contacted his patients and tried to steer them to other providers, boycotted his practice and made false and defamatory statements against him.

In addition, the complaint states Wilcox was subject to “unreasonable restrictions” that kept him from performing some procedures. His emergency room surgical coverage schedule was cut, which also contributed to his financial hardship.

Wilcox’s attorney, David M. Korrey, said the restrictions on his client’s practice so curtailed his earning capacity that his employment at HDMC effectively has ended.

 “It wiped him out,” the attorney said in a telephone interview.

 Korrey also declared that although the California Medical Board exonerated Wilcox and he could have applied to other hospitals to augment his income, these other hospitals would not have welcomed  his application after they learned another facility had restricted his privileges.

District officials acknowledged this week they have been served with the summons and complaint.

The health care district’s attorney, Carlo Coppo of DiCaro, Coppo and Popke, provided a statement on behalf of the district,

“The Medical Center believes Dr. Wilcox’s lawsuit is both procedurally and substantively meritless,” the attorneys wrote.

They said the matter has been referred to outside counsel, “who will vigorously defend this matter in court.”

The statement goes on, It would be inappropriate to comment on personnel and/or medical staff matters, due to issues of confidentiality and privilege. Because of the pending lawsuit, the Medical Center will not ‘litigate in the press’ and will make no further comment on this matter.

“The Medical Center will pursue its legitimate and forceful defenses to this meritless litigation and fully expects to prevail before a judge or jury.”

Wilcox’s attorney anticipates a trial in two to three years, when his client would hope to recover wages lost due to the restrictions, and clear his professional status.

However, he noted that should Wilcox have his practice privileges restored in the meantime, it would reduce his claim for lost wages “considerably.”

© 2015 Hi-Desert Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss

Welcome to the discussion

Please respect this forum and your colleagues by keeping your discussions civil and on-topic. We reserve the right to remove any comments with abusive, obscene, defamatory or prejudiced language or innuendos. Threats of harming another person and comments celebrating harm done to another person will not be tolerated. Use the “report” link to let the editor know about abusive or questionable posts.


  • ForMyMom posted at 3:00 pm on Wed, Apr 6, 2011.

    ForMyMom Posts: 0

    The 76 yr old woman was my mother. Although some staff were very nice, we were appalled at her treatment. The community needs to rally behind Dr. Wilcox. "takes courage" is right above, HDMC should be a jewel for the community. What happened to my Mom should never, ever happen again. Demand that these people be removed, it may save your life.

  • takes courage posted at 2:12 pm on Thu, Mar 31, 2011.

    takes courage Posts: 0

    Amazing that a doctor whose only crime is trying to improve service for patients is demonized by management!As a former employee, I know the good people who work for Hi Desert Medical Center are “cut off and intimidated” whenever they challenge policy and procedures that are unsafe or illegal.Hi Desert Medical Center should be a jewel for the community rather than the place patients fear to go for medical care.Perhaps this will be the start of some much needed change!

  • onlyme posted at 2:18 am on Wed, Mar 30, 2011.

    onlyme Posts: 2

    pretty sad. I've heard so many things bout this hospital and they have NOT been good. I have also heard the quotes: "bandaid station" and "you check in and don't check out". I am afraid to go to this hospital. We have to go the ER here since it is closer than Desert for an emergency but it scares me. My husband ended up there after a motercycle accident. they were so so bad and careless. I have to say I am afraid of this hospital. I really hope this Dr. gets good representation I hope it goes all well for him. that is a shame they would do this to someone who wants to make this a descent hospital. What a shame they have to cover this stuff up.


Yucca Valley, CA

Current Conditions

Humidity: 16%
Winds: WSW at 15mph
Feels Like: 93°

Your Extended Forecast


High 96°/Low 71°


High 97°/Low 71°
Mainly sunny


High 98°/Low 73°


High 98°/Low 73°
Mainly sunny
default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

Follow us on Facebook

Most Commented